
In 2008, the Phillies had home-field advantage in both the NLDS and the NLCS. The Tampa Bay Rays had the home-field advantage in the World Series, but the Phillies quickly wrestled it from them by splitting the first two games at Tropicana Field.
After today’s 5-4 loss to the Rockies, they enter territory they haven’t explored since the 2007 NLDS against the Rockies: they have relinquished home-field advantage and head to their opponent’s home park.
For a team that thrives on urgency, guess who’s at the door? A potential do-or-die situation! Leaving Philly for with a 1-1 split may actually be the best for our heroes. Should they be fortunate enough to slip by the Rockies and make it to another NLCS, they may open the series in Los Angeles against a better Dodgers team than they faced in 2008: a Dodgers team that would love to exact a measure of revenge on the Phils.
If the Phillies pull off another trip to the World Series, they could very well be facing a resurgent, focused Yankees team that resembles the 2008 Rays in no way.
It’s time for the Phillies to face some adversity and see if this team has the intestinal fortitude and desire to take their 2009 season somewhere truly special.
*********************************
We won’t know until tomorrow which pitcher Charlie Manuel will go with to start Game 3 in Colorado. Pedro wants the ball. Blanton can take the ball (despite throwing 19 pitches) according to Charlie. And J.A. Happ wants the ball, despite being hit by a line drive in Game 2 and leaving after throwing just 4 pitches.
While Charlie didn’t necessarily do himself any favors by having Happ and Blanton pitch in relief today, they didn’t throw enough pitches to count themselves out of the next game. More on Charlie’s management of the game later.
I think it is great that we have 3 other starters after Lee and Hamels who are ready willing and able to start, even if they were called upon on a day off to pitch in relief.
Pedro wants the ball, and that is great, but for my money, Happ should get the start assuming he has no lingering issues with the leg injury from today’s game. If the Phillies had gone up 2-0 in the series today, I would have probably not pitched Happ in Game 3, instead opting to go with one of the righties. Now that the series is tied 1-1, let’s go with the guy who already shut this team down once this year. Let’s go with the guy who went into Charlie’s office to state his case for starting. Let’s go with the guy who is a lefty against a team that hasn’t exactly crushed lefty pitching, despite Cole Hamels’ struggles today.
*********************************
Did Charlie Manuel over-manage today’s game? Perhaps a little, but his in-game decisions hardly cost the team the game. They could have unintended consequences in future games of this series, including his use of the bullpen.
With the Phillies down 4-0 and Cole Hamels out of the game, Charlie went with Joe Blanton instead of Kyle Kendrick or Chad Durbin. Brad Lidge’s season-long struggles have certainly cast a pall over the bullpen, but a 4-0 deficit in the 6th inning screamed for Kyle Kendrick or Chad Durbin to toe the slab in an effort to keep the deficit at 4. Since September call-ups, Kendrick went 3-0 with a 3.00 ERA and most importantly, looked far more confident on the mound than he had at the end of last year or the beginning of 2009. Charlie needs to be able to trust him if he’s on the roster.
After only needing Cliff Lee to win Game 1, Charlie may have tore a shoulder tendon after gesturing to the bullpen 6 times for relievers. Major props to Scott Eyre and Antonio Bastardo, who were both thrust into the unenviable task of cleaning up others’ messes and performed admirably in keeping the damage to an absolute minimum. Ryan Madson looked great in the ninth, needing only 7 pitches to close out the inning.
*********************************
Losing this game was obviously a huge disappointment, especially when the winning run was standing at 1st base in the person of Jimmy Rollins. The Phils almost won the game in spite of Cole Hamels’ less than average performance.
But I was really impressed with the fight in the Phils today once they were down. They outhit the Rockies, pitched mostly lights out in relief and had a chance to steal it at the end. Credit Aaron Cook for holding the Phillies in check during the first half of the game. The Phillies have 23 hits through 2 games and the middle of the order is batting .500 in the series.
*********************************
After the game, we learned that Cole Hamels’ wife Heidi was in labor with their first child. Hamels left right after his day was over in the 5th inning. Was Cole distracted by the fact that he was so close to becoming a father for the first time? I doubt it. What hurt Hamels today was a continuation of him allowing his emotions to get the better of him sometimes, as evidenced by his demeanor in the first inning. His worst pitch was to light-hitting Yorvit Torrealba, who deposited it with authority into the left field seats.
Jim Salisbury says that Hamels needs to find a third pitch that he will actually use.
3 Comments